Review is cellular senescence an example of antagonistic. Pleiotropy and human disorders biology for majors i. Antagonistic pleiotropy results when a single trait is influenced by many genes b. Crisprcas9 knockout screens in chemotherapytreated acute myeloid leukemia cells help map the drugdependent genetic basis of fitness tradeoffs antagonistic pleiotropy. Sickle cell anemia, betathalassemia, and cystic fibrosis are some other examples of the role antagonistic pleiotropy may play in genetic disorders. Is cellular senescence an example of antagonistic pleiotropy. One example is a theory of aging first developed by g. Pleiotropy is most often a bad thing, as many diseases are due to a gene controlling so many traits at once.
Antagonistic pleiotropy has been the dominant theory for evolution of aging since it was first proposed 60 years ago. George williams 1957 paper developed the antagonistic pleiotropy hypothesis of aging, which had previously been hinted at by peter medawar. As science informs public policy, decision making, and so many aspects of our everyday lives, a scientifically literate society is crucial. Antagonistic pleiotropy typically is measured in terms of darwinian fitness, with improvements in fitness in one situation corresponding to declines in fitness in another. Sickle cell anemia is also a disease caused by pleiotropy.
I think this is a good time to introduce the term pleiotropy. However, it is important to remember that although genetic correlations can sometimes create the need to exercise more care in. Biology the production of diverse effects, especially the production by a. Campisi, 2005, which is an influential explanation of how organisms could evolve mechanisms that reduce. This of course was the genesis of the antagonistic pleiotropy theory. Pdf antagonistic pleiotropy has been the dominant theory for evolution of aging since it was first proposed 60 years ago. The basis of antagonistic pleiotropy in hfq mutations that have. A half century ago, the antagonistic pleiotropy a p theory had solved a mystery of aging, by postulating genes beneficial early in life at the cost of aging. A classic example used to illustrate pleiotropy is huntingtons disease this is a congenital syndrome caused by a gene variant that actually increases fertility early in life, but typically around age 40, neurological symptoms begin, affecting coordination and causing mood swings. In fact, the abovedescribed thinking appears to be vulnerable to two main lines of criticism. In our model of antagonistic pleiotropy, we consider the effect of selection upon the optimal level of senescent deterioration subject to some tradeoff between agespecific fecundity and condition.
Here, we describe a novel form of antagonistic pleiotropy that operates. Some, maybe most, genes have multiple functions, and this theory says that genes with important functions in youth cannot be weeded out when they cause aging. Antagonistic definition in the cambridge english dictionary. The antagonistic pleiotropy theory of aging was first proposed by g. The antagonistic pleiotropy theory has a number of difficulties. In an age of epigenetics, does antagonistic pleiotropy.
Antagonistic pleiotropy is when one gene controls for more than one trait, where at least one of these traits is beneficial to the organisms fitness early. The examples of antagonistic pleiotropy cited above demonstrate the widespread nature of this phenomenon in terms of physiological systems and tissues as well as mechanisms of action. By definition, pleiotropy is a situation in which one gene controls for the expression of multiple phenotypic traits. I coined the term antagonistic pleiotropy, which i should explain, an idea that dates back to the 1930s. The previous examples are based on specifically characterized genes. Furthermore, an antagonistic effect of added amino acids, such as glutamine, on sucroseinduced gs expression was observed. To explain its evolutionary origin, some authors have proposed an hypothesis that has become the common view in the literature. Antagonistic pleiotropy occurs when one of those traits is harmful. Indeed, examples of pleiotropy have been observed, but there are also many. Antagonistic pleiotropy generally refers to genetic controls such as testosterone or estrogen levels that are beneficial during the bodys reproductive stage but that can be bad at older ages houseflies that are kept in a container so they can only walk around live up to 2. There are also compelling examples of disease risk variants that confer fitness. First, additional evidence is emerging of putative bene. The antagonistic pleiotropy hypothesis was first proposed by george c. Examples of how to use pleiotropy in a sentence from the cambridge dictionary labs.
Antagonistic pleiotropy as a widespread mechanism for the. Stefano giaimo 1,2 and fabrizio d adda di fagagna 1,3 1 ifom foundation the firc institute of molecular oncology foundation. For example, one study suggests that since follicular depletion in human females causes both more regular cycles in early life and loss of fertility later in life. Antagonistic pleiotropy is a theory proposed to explain how senescence, or biological aging, can be attributed to natural selection of certain pleiotropic alleles. Antagonistic pleiotropy synonyms, antagonistic pleiotropy pronunciation, antagonistic pleiotropy translation, english dictionary definition of antagonistic pleiotropy. Recent developments point toward possibly major progress. Those who are homozygous for the hbs allele, meaning that they have two hbs alleles of the hemoglobin gene, have a short life span due to the negative impact damage to multiple body systems of the sickle cell trait. The antagonistic pleiotropy hypothesis suggests that the fierce selection. Antagonistic pleiotropy results when a gene has different functions in two or more organisms d. For example, while there do appear to be tradeoffs between reproduction and longevity in mammals, the. Antagonistic pleiotropy ap is today the bestaccepted theory for the evolutionary origin of aging.
That is because life is not perfection but incessant change. Antagonistic pleiotropy, mutation accumulation, and human. So though aging is inevitable and emerges from antagonistic pleiotropy, it can be attacked. The latest volume in the bestselling series from dubbed the worlds smartest website by the guardianbrings together 206 of the worlds most innovative thinkers to discuss the scientific concepts that everyone should know. Macdonald hr, wilson a, radtke f 1993 a novel gene containing a. In the broader sense, why doesnt the body repair itself indefinitely.
For example, a decade ago, the japanese biologist shinya yamanaka found. Antagonistic pleiotropy is an effect that is beneficial to an organisms fitness early in life, but which causes functional decline and aging phenotypes later in life. In this standard view, aging exists because the benefits of enhanced fertility early in life are linked logically or physically to. Antagonistic pleiotropy results when an allele causes an adaptive change. Alleles experiencing antagonistic pleiotrophy should always be strongly selected against c. Is antagonistic pleiotropy ubiquitous in aging biology. Studies focused on various bacteria have shown that antagonistic pleiotropy can be heavily based on the environment and on the various resources available to the organism. Genetic evidence supporting this hypothesis was unavailable then, but has accumulated recently. This poses a dilemma for the logic of the theory, which depends critically on the assumption that pleiotropy has imposed an. According to ap theory, aging is a side effect of genes that are selected for their contribution to fertility and other essential components of individual fitness. In this work, in addition to legitimate examples of genetic pleiotropy figure 5a and b, it is suggested that some traits correlated with mutant alleles are only indirectly associated with that trait, and this situation has been called mediated pleiotropy figure 5c. Arg is prevalent in humans, but novel among primates, which.
Genes affected in human genetic disorders are often pleiotropic. Antagonistic pleiotropy, mutation accumulation, and springer link abstract. Sickle cell trait is an example of antagonistic pleiotropy in that the hbs allele mutation of the hemoglobin gene provides advantages and disadvantages for survival. Antagonistic pleiotropy refers to a situation in which a single gene creates multiple competing effects, such that beneficial effects of a trait created by the gene are offset by losses in other traits. Recently it was argued, however, that there are very few clearcut examples of antagonistically pleiotropic a p genes other than p53. While it suppresses cancer, it also suppresses stem cells that replenish old tissues.
Numerous examples of antagonistic pleiotropy have been previously. For example, people with the hereditary disorder marfan syndrome may have a constellation of seemingly unrelated symptoms 3. In biology, what is the antagonistic pleiotropy hypothesis. Antagonistic pleiotropy definition of antagonistic. Indeed, examples of pleiotropy have been observed, but there are also many examples of mutations that lead to longer lifespan without apparent cost. The antagonistic pleiotropy ap theory of aging has solved the socalled unsolved. Some of the genetic disorders linked to pleiotropy include sickle cell anemia, marfan syndrome and phenylketonuria, among others. Another way of saying it is you take the bad with the good or there is no such thing as a free lunch. Antagonistic pleiotropy implies stabilizing selection on the fitness components separately, which usually tends to reduce genetic variance. Antagonistic pleiotropy may be particularly relevant in plant viruses as an unavoidable consequence of.
Did you also coin antagonistic pleiotropy and protagonist pleiotropy. Williams in 1957 as an evolutionary explanation for senescence. Here we examine the strength of evidence for antagonistic pleiotropy in. We identified a number of examples of antagonistic pleiotropy where. Ros is a molecular example of antagonistic pleiotropy, being controlled during normal development for its signaling effects, for example, those regulating neuroplasticity, but becoming deleterious in brain with age, due to declining resistance to its detrimental actions and its increased production free radical theory of aging. Antagonistic pleiotropy, reversal of dominance, and. Essentially, this theory is close to the mutation accumulation theory of aging. Antagonistic pleiotropy is a prevailing theory today, but williams was wrong. These tradeoffs, known as antagonistic pleiotropy, are common, perhaps ubiquitous. It is widely considered to be an important foundation for the evolution of aging, in that natural selection operates strongly during early life, a period characterized by tooth and claw.
The antagonistic pleiotropy theory of senescence is the most convincing theoretical explanation of the existence of aging. For example, a decade ago, the japanese biologist shinya yamanaka found four crucial genes that reset the clock of the fertilized egg. Antagonistic pleiotropy and the evolution of wing dimorphism in the sand cricket, gryllus firmus d a roff 1 heredity volume 65, pages 169 177 1990 cite this article. As occurring within a single organism simultaneously, as occurring within the same organism but with a gap between. Have specific genetic examples of antagonistic pleiotropy been. Is alzheimers disease an example of antagonistic pleiotropy. Unfortunately, the process of antagonistic pleiotropy may result in an altered evolutionary path with delayed adaptation, in addition to effectively cutting the overall benefit of any alleles by roughly half. An example is the p53 gene, which suppresses cancer but also suppresses stem cells, which replenish wornout tissue. Revisiting the antagonistic pleiotropy theory of aging. The antagonistic pleiotropy theory of senescence is the most convincing. Pleiotropy occurs when a single gene affects more than one distinct and seemingly unrelated trait. There are various types of pleiotropy, including developmental pleiotropy, gene pleiotropy, selectional pleiotropy and antagonistic pleiotropy, all of which we will discuss in more detail below. We conclude that, even though tradeoffs in fitness components may be common, antagonistic pleiotropy probably plays a limited role in explaining the persistence of genetic variation in fitness components. The hbs allele is perhaps the best known and most widely used example of antagonistic pleiotropy in discussions of the topic in human disease due to the clear deleterious effect in homozygotes combined with a clear advantage in heterozygotes.
Antagonistic pleiotropy an overview sciencedirect topics. The p53 gene presents a good example of antagonistic pleiotropy. Literal translation of antagonistic pleiotropy is different effects in opposition. Below we provide two examples of the antagonistic pleiotropy hypothesis in natural populations followed by more specific examples in each of the four commonly studied laboratory organisms. One problem with the antagonistic pleiotropy theory is that the force of natural selection, although apparently progressively smaller in older individuals is not zero, even according to the traditional model. There is a number of antagonistically pleiotropic genes including genes acting in insulin signalling or genes taking part in the synthesis of lipophilic hormones. Antagonistic definition of antagonistic by medical. For example, phenylketonuria is a disease caused by pleiotropy. These situations can be especially different environments or instead different.
Pleiotropy is the phenomenon where one gene controls for more than one phenotypic trait in an organism. Using antagonistic pleiotropy to design a chemotherapy. Antagonistic pleiotropy in human disease springerlink. Knowledge of which traits are antagonistic can be utilized to manage the impact of selection decisions on other correlated traits. In many cases, this multitrait effect is because a gene codes for a certain product, whereas that protein. In antagonistic pleiotropy, an allele that has a negative impact on an organism can be favored by natural selection if the allele also produces advantageous effects. The arms are an important means of defence of our vulnerable points, including the head, chest, and abdomen, as well as of antagonistic connections to others. Indeed, what antagonistic pleiotropy tells us is something fundamental.
599 164 319 153 101 106 736 349 786 697 1093 1261 450 1402 307 1504 287 584 1117 1240 256 756 1095 569 97 389 542 1329 1129 194 1287 543 1084 936 782 474 697 1315 1494 873 1335 23 1163 1181